Do you have any examples or reasons that Oshui shouldn't be considered a maran/goodie? Other than his belief that "neutral isn't a get out of jail free card" which frankly has always been part of the Baer religion and Maran canon.

Some people mention his looting. But as Oshui remarked himself, this was usually the case of a lowbie looting the corpse. I think the player kept a quite reasonable attitude through being full looted after going for retrieval against 5 to 1 odds.

So, to be clear, I'm in the dark was what constituted Oshui's "NON_GOOD" behavior.