Java | Sat 26-Jun-10 10:19 PM |
Member since 07th Apr 2003
1055 posts
| |
|
#33620, "See, I STRONGLY disagree with this.."
|
What makes someone "good", in the first place?
In the world of CF, doing nothing, just "existing" does not make you good. If you spend your life on a farm, taking care of your family and not getting involved in any other interests you're most likely "neutral" (hence all the neutral farmer mobs out there).
Obviously, everyone is "innocent" until they are "guilty" of something. Correct? So what is that farmer guilty of? He's guilty of "doing nothing". The fact that he "does nothing" would make him a "bystander", wouldn't it?
So it seems, logically, that that farmer is an "innocent" "bystander". Meaning he shouldn't be killed.
Again, I think you can find RP justifications for killing the majority of neutral mobs. HOWEVER, any truly good character NEEDS those justifications. "I want his gold" is NOT justification for killing someone for a good character. Killing for the sake of gold alone is NOT a good act.
Now, you're an Imm, so it's your prerogative if you want to turn the other cheek to that sort of behavior. But the danger of your Imm tag is that newer players reading this thread will think your viewpoint represents the entire Immstaff. History tells us that your viewpoint is NOT shared universally, with the playerbase or your fellow Imms.
|
|
|
I deleted over this. I'm ####ing pissed.
[View all] , Pro, Fri 25-Jun-10 06:55 AM
Time to lock this up and move on? n/t,
Pro,
29-Jun-10 07:53 PM, #100
You sure? You done? n/t,
Lhydia,
29-Jun-10 09:39 PM, #101
Dear Santa Zulgh...,
Gabe,
28-Jun-10 10:58 PM, #97
Because Gabe is a BAMF, this should be considered. nt,
sleepy,
29-Jun-10 12:58 AM, #98
Ignore command,
Tsunami,
26-Jun-10 02:08 PM, #56
Completely OOC.,
Pro,
26-Jun-10 02:54 PM, #59
RE: Completely OOC.,
Tsunami,
26-Jun-10 03:01 PM, #60
He's referencing a log on Dio,
sleepy,
26-Jun-10 03:30 PM, #62
Oh yeah.,
Pro,
26-Jun-10 04:23 PM, #66
So...,
Tsunami,
26-Jun-10 04:42 PM, #68
So..,
Pro,
26-Jun-10 04:52 PM, #69
You're really, really dumb.~,
blackbird,
26-Jun-10 10:02 PM, #75
While you're busy being a vigilante...,
Splntrd,
26-Jun-10 11:45 PM, #78
I don't recall breaking any rules.,
Pro,
27-Jun-10 11:05 PM, #92
RE: I don't recall breaking any rules.,
Eskelian,
28-Jun-10 02:38 AM, #95
RE: I don't recall breaking any rules.,
Splntrd,
29-Jun-10 02:19 PM, #99
Please move this to another board. st,
Kalageadon,
26-Jun-10 08:24 AM, #51
Being the one that dealt with this...,
Nnaeshuk,
25-Jun-10 12:31 PM, #43
I'm sitting here with the source of all my angst.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 01:48 PM, #45
In all seriousness,
incognito,
26-Jun-10 08:18 AM, #50
Cosign n/t,
Dervish,
26-Jun-10 09:56 AM, #52
RE: In all seriousness,
Lhydia,
26-Jun-10 10:17 AM, #53
RE: In all seriousness,
incognito,
26-Jun-10 03:38 PM, #65
Hahaha. n/t,
Lhydia,
26-Jun-10 05:29 PM, #70
Conversely,
Malakhi,
26-Jun-10 12:34 PM, #54
In my strictest goodie characters..,
Java,
26-Jun-10 12:43 PM, #55
Shackling the benevolent,
Swordsosaurus,
26-Jun-10 02:32 PM, #57
Well, it disgusted me when I played a paladin,
incognito,
26-Jun-10 03:37 PM, #64
Oh I agree with you..,
Java,
26-Jun-10 08:33 PM, #72
Dragons are sentient beings,
Nightgaunt_,
27-Jun-10 04:11 PM, #85
Hmm..,
Java,
27-Jun-10 06:37 PM, #86
I have always, always..,
Swordsosaurus,
27-Jun-10 06:53 PM, #88
That makes me think of Nep's alternate,
Mekantos,
27-Jun-10 09:13 PM, #89
Ah, you got me,
Swordsosaurus,
27-Jun-10 10:53 PM, #91
Yup:,
Daevryn,
28-Jun-10 12:45 AM, #94
####ing Tolkien!,
Pro,
27-Jun-10 11:07 PM, #93
Dragons have feelings too!,
Mekantos,
27-Jun-10 06:41 PM, #87
Aww, you shouldn't have taken that Dragon's newbie brea...,
DurNominator,
28-Jun-10 05:51 PM, #96
Then you sir, are neutral.,
Pro,
26-Jun-10 02:48 PM, #58
That's perfectly acceptable "Good" roleplay.,
Java,
26-Jun-10 03:09 PM, #61
This guy says he's smart?,
Pro,
26-Jun-10 04:07 PM, #67
You're retarded. NT,
TMNS,
26-Jun-10 10:16 PM, #76
You seem to have misinterpreted me,
incognito,
26-Jun-10 03:35 PM, #63
No, I understood you.,
Malakhi,
26-Jun-10 09:41 PM, #74
See, I STRONGLY disagree with this..,
Java,
26-Jun-10 10:19 PM #77
RE: See, I STRONGLY disagree with this..,
Malakhi,
27-Jun-10 12:44 AM, #81
RE: No, I understood you.,
Isildur,
27-Jun-10 12:42 AM, #80
RE: No, I understood you.,
Malakhi,
27-Jun-10 01:18 AM, #82
That surprises me a bit,
incognito,
27-Jun-10 03:42 AM, #83
I'm kind of in agreement here, sickening as it is,
Runaktla,
26-Jun-10 08:15 PM, #71
Consider, you contradict yourself in you attempt to sla...,
Pro,
26-Jun-10 08:46 PM, #73
RE: Consider, you contradict yourself in you attempt to...,
Runaktla,
27-Jun-10 12:10 AM, #79
And how ABOUT those ultra-mature prays of yours.,
Java,
25-Jun-10 10:47 AM, #37
Hi Pro. I'm with you.,
Marin,
25-Jun-10 10:28 AM, #35
This is retarded.,
Java,
25-Jun-10 10:34 AM, #36
Those prayers were Skraag.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 11:36 AM, #40
You should seek therapy for your RP OCD. n/t,
Lhydia,
25-Jun-10 08:01 AM, #29
RE: I deleted over this. I'm ####ing pissed.,
sorlag (Anonymous),
25-Jun-10 07:11 AM, #28
You're actively LOOKING for stuff to be mad about.,
Java,
25-Jun-10 12:22 AM, #27
This.,
Twist,
25-Jun-10 11:34 AM, #39
I'm willing to admit that,,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 11:53 AM, #41
Buddy,
Mekantos,
25-Jun-10 11:59 AM, #42
40yo SWM,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 01:30 PM, #44
45lbs in 2 to 3 months?,
Mekantos,
25-Jun-10 01:59 PM, #46
Since I split with my partner,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 03:17 PM, #47
So you 'lost' your 'partner' and stopped working out yo...,
Lhydia,
25-Jun-10 03:14 PM, #48
I'm not sure what the deal is here...,
colospgsbryan,
25-Jun-10 03:50 AM, #24
RE: I'm not sure what the deal is here...,
Eskelian,
25-Jun-10 06:38 AM, #25
Is it just me?,
Lokain,
25-Jun-10 03:49 AM, #23
Considering the key not being there is a BUG.(ooc mecha...,
Jhyrbian,
25-Jun-10 01:25 AM, #14
RE: Considering the key not being there is a BUG.(ooc m...,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 02:18 AM, #19
For argument's sake...,
Twist,
25-Jun-10 10:58 AM, #38
RE: I deleted over this. I'm ####ing pissed.,
Isildur,
25-Jun-10 12:16 AM, #3
Call it what you want.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 12:38 AM, #8
Where did you see them get rewarded?,
Java,
25-Jun-10 12:46 AM, #9
RE: Call it what you want.,
Isildur,
25-Jun-10 01:36 AM, #15
RE: Call it what you want.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 01:55 AM, #17
No wonder you still suck at this game.,
Jhyrbian,
25-Jun-10 02:35 AM, #26
because I stay in role and play in align and,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 03:06 AM, #21
You should start your own mud, with your own rules.,
Jhyrbian,
25-Jun-10 03:27 AM, #22
RE: Call it what you want.,
Isildur,
25-Jun-10 08:38 AM, #30
Don't forget..,
Java,
25-Jun-10 09:38 AM, #31
First of all, you've used the word Tattle at least 4 ti...,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 10:15 AM, #33
You're delusional.,
TMNS,
25-Jun-10 10:27 AM, #34
You got to learn at some point.,
wareagle,
25-Jun-10 12:02 AM, #2
Here's the deal.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 12:28 AM, #4
And you getting pissed off about it WAS IC? nt,
Java,
25-Jun-10 12:25 AM, #5
I get it, I really do.,
wareagle,
25-Jun-10 12:29 AM, #6
How often do I unload like this?,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 12:32 AM, #7
You are always complaining about something. NT,
TMNS,
25-Jun-10 12:48 AM, #10
Umm constantly?,
ORB,
25-Jun-10 01:09 AM, #13
RE: Umm constantly?,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 01:49 AM, #16
Dude...that's on a totally different level.,
sleepy,
25-Jun-10 02:00 AM, #18
RE: Dude...that's on a totally different level.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 02:55 AM, #20
RE: Umm constantly?,
ORB,
25-Jun-10 09:52 AM, #32
I don't follow people over cliffs.,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 06:11 PM, #49
I thought you said. . .,
dwimmerling,
27-Jun-10 03:19 PM, #84
Read what you wrote, look inside yourself and say...,
Pro,
27-Jun-10 10:30 PM, #90
On a side note...,
Pro,
25-Jun-10 12:50 AM, #11
There is no rule that says goodies can't kill neutrals.,
TMNS,
25-Jun-10 12:56 AM, #12
FWIW, I've seen many good-aligned chars attack the guar...,
sleepy,
24-Jun-10 11:29 PM, #1
| |
|