Why on earth would she kick Nacklewig out of the Inn, and not the maniac trying to kill the guard?

Why on earth would a mortal offer a God "options"? You have no leverage whatsoever. This is sheer hubris, and I'm shocked you weren't slain or plagued.

Why the hell would the patron God of the Inn do anything to help anyone outside trying to kill anyone else inside? That doesn't make any sense; her loyalty is to those INSIDE. She has no reason to help you, and every reason to defend Nacklewig, despite him being a ####up. How you could possibly expect this to turn out in your favor is beyond me.