Subject: "RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #64041
Show all folders

UmironTue 12-Jul-16 12:54 PM
Member since 29th May 2017
1495 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to add this author to your buddy list
#64042, "RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards."


          

>Hi all,
>
>I was curious if the staff would consider either lowering edge
>costs across the board, or implementing new ways to obtain
>edge points in addition to those already existing.

I'm not interested in lowering edge costs across the board. We've tossed around some ideas on new methods and some unrelated things, but nothing that has grown legs yet.

>A common theme to posts on both forums seems to be that people
>REALLY like edges - myself included. They provide a route of
>character customization/building which is a huge appeal to
>many players of this type of game.

An observation more than an argument:

Ironically, while there are a LOT of edges (see below), relatively few of them are remotely popular. So while in theory edges allow for a huge degree of customization, in practice they don't really result in customization so much as they amplify the strength or mitigate the weaknesses of builds that still end up being built and played the exact same way. In essence, things are just as 'cookie-cutter' as they would be without edges at all.

That's our fault, of course. Unfortunately, the only solution to that is for a very knowledgeable coder to go back and refactor individual edges and those stars just haven't aligned yet.

>Would you consider:
>
>Automatically giving a character X edge points throughout
>ranks (every 10 ranks or something)

I would not.

>Putting the obs/explore edge point notches back where they
>were (every 1k instead of 2k/3k)

I would not, both because I think it's turned out to be a ####ty mechanic (in the sense that it no longer achieves it's original goal) and because I think the current math is fair. Remember, when that feature was originally coded it was *not* typical, let alone possible, to rack up the kind of EXP/OXP that it is today. Part of that change was merely keeping the value of that exchange rate, so to speak, in line and reasonable.

>Giving edge points, or a fraction thereof for every item
>retrieval instead of starting it at 10.

I would not.

>Giving edge points for hours played (after level 11) at
>intervals 20/50/100/150/200/etc. (to avoid abuse of idling a
>lowbie with PK protection)

I would not, though we've discussed something kinda/sorta like this that I'm not going to elaborate on because then if we don't do it I'll get extra hate mail for a couple of weeks. I will say that what we discussed would not be interesting to min/maxers or players whose interest in edges is predicated on PK.

>I'd personally like to see more edges in the game. Not only
>were they vastly popular (every time you guys introduced new
>ones it was quite well received). They add a lot of flavor to
>the game, and serve as goals in addition to simply ranking/PK
>stats/etc.

It's possible we'll see new edges in the future related to changed class designs (e.g., neo-Shaman) or as compliments to new features. But, given that there are already 800+ edges I'd say coding more for the sake of variety is near the absolute bottom of our priority list. Besides, I hear nobody can afford them anyway.

>I understand this is a touchy subject, and I do not mean to
>beat a dead horse. Thank you guys for any response this may
>bring.
>

You're welcome.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicEdges - NOT a post about PK rewards. [View all] , Sarien, Tue 12-Jul-16 12:11 PM
Reply The nice things are strictly rationed in today's CF., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 01:41 AM, #23
Reply RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards., Umiron, 12-Jul-16 12:54 PM #1
     Reply RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards., LoverofCF (Anonymous), 12-Jul-16 01:12 PM, #2
     Reply who does the work?, Dallevian, 12-Jul-16 01:23 PM, #3
     Reply I'd do it. n/t, Saagkri, 12-Jul-16 01:48 PM, #6
          Reply You know how/where to apply to the staff nt, Destuvius, 12-Jul-16 05:12 PM, #10
               Reply I'd do it., Murphy, 12-Jul-16 06:46 PM, #11
     Reply RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards., Umiron, 12-Jul-16 01:55 PM, #7
     Reply RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards., LoverofCF (Anonymous), 12-Jul-16 02:59 PM, #9
     Reply It's not just player ideas., Jormyr, 12-Jul-16 10:55 PM, #15
          Reply Start passing the hat around for a new keyboard. , Demos, 12-Jul-16 10:28 PM, #18
     Reply Followup - Your cookie cutter comment., Sarien, 12-Jul-16 01:25 PM, #4
     Reply RE: Followup - Your cookie cutter comment., Umiron, 12-Jul-16 01:36 PM, #5
          Reply RE: Followup - Your cookie cutter comment., TJHuron, 12-Jul-16 02:06 PM, #8
          Reply Bards are no longer my favorite class, Murphy, 12-Jul-16 06:50 PM, #12
          Reply That was actually the one class I had in mind when maki..., TJHuron, 12-Jul-16 07:40 PM, #13
          Reply Bards still are my fav. class, lasentia, 13-Jul-16 07:05 AM, #25
               Reply I'm not revealing any of my secrets., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 07:58 AM, #26
               Reply I would trade every edge I could get for bash protectio..., lasentia, 13-Jul-16 10:08 AM, #29
                    Reply Dude, you don't understand Murph. He needs at least 15..., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 06:52 PM, #38
                    Reply You know nothing, Same., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 07:44 PM, #47
                    Reply Play a centaur bard., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 08:47 PM, #53
               Reply I think you need to know the bard type to answer this, TJHuron, 13-Jul-16 08:10 AM, #28
                    Reply RE: I think you need to know the bard type to answer th..., lasentia, 13-Jul-16 10:35 AM, #30
                         Reply Well, one can make your argument for any class and edge..., TJHuron, 13-Jul-16 11:16 AM, #31
                         Reply I think we do agree, lasentia, 13-Jul-16 02:57 PM, #32
                              Reply RE: I think we do agree, stlucian1992, 13-Jul-16 03:59 PM, #35
                         Reply Honestly, Perfect Pitch was the only "must have"., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 06:53 PM, #39
                              Reply Perfect pitch is not required, Murphy, 13-Jul-16 08:21 PM, #52
          Reply Ironically, I go entirely the other way., Jormyr, 12-Jul-16 07:53 PM, #14
          Reply I found a few like that., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 01:38 AM, #22
          Reply RE: Ironically, I go entirely the other way., Saagkri, 13-Jul-16 08:08 AM, #27
          Reply RE: Followup - Your cookie cutter comment., Umiron, 12-Jul-16 09:05 PM, #16
               Reply Armchair balancing., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 01:38 AM, #21
                    Reply RE: Armchair balancing., Umiron, 13-Jul-16 05:42 PM, #36
                         Reply This is why I've never applied. =) n/t, Lhydia, 13-Jul-16 06:43 PM, #37
                         Reply Not for nothing, but remember Murph is ESL., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 06:56 PM, #40
                         Reply "Has ESL", not "is ESL"., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 08:51 PM, #54
                              Reply ESL = English Speaking Louse, TMNS, 13-Jul-16 09:32 PM, #55
                                   Reply You stinking RLB., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 11:21 PM, #57
                         Reply Oh I understand, Murphy, 13-Jul-16 07:48 PM, #44
                              Reply RE: Oh I understand, Umiron, 13-Jul-16 07:46 PM, #48
                                   Reply One caveat here, Murphy, 13-Jul-16 08:00 PM, #49
                                        Reply RE: One caveat here, Umiron, 13-Jul-16 08:09 PM, #50
                                             Reply I judge from my own experience, Murphy, 13-Jul-16 08:16 PM, #51
          Reply This made my night!, SPN, 12-Jul-16 11:06 PM, #19
          Reply In practice, there are huge gamechanger edges, Sertius, 13-Jul-16 03:21 PM, #33
               Reply Buki edges are super cheap., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 03:29 PM, #34
               Reply Hey! I came up with that regen in forest's better edge..., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 06:57 PM, #41
     Reply RE: Edges - NOT a post about PK rewards., Bemused, 12-Jul-16 09:17 PM, #17
     Reply Plenty of edge points is what allows one to NOT min-max..., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 01:35 AM, #20
     Reply No, your ass broke it with your 32 edged-character. FF..., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 06:59 PM, #42
          Reply 31-edged., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 07:42 PM, #45
     Reply Edge popularity doesn't measure strength or usefulness., KaguMaru, 13-Jul-16 05:40 AM, #24
     Reply They've been scarce for all of 6 months or so., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 07:01 PM, #43
          Reply 30 edges is fine and it never hurt the game., Murphy, 13-Jul-16 07:43 PM, #46
          Reply My funstick disagrees., TMNS, 13-Jul-16 09:33 PM, #56
          Reply RC rewards:, Iunna, 14-Jul-16 03:16 PM, #61
          Reply Nah, throw them a minor power., TMNS, 14-Jul-16 06:21 PM, #62
          Reply Yeah but that sounds boring., Iunna, 14-Jul-16 06:40 PM, #63
               Reply RE: Yeah but that sounds boring., Umiron, 14-Jul-16 06:47 PM, #64
          Reply The fact that you actually had 7 legacies makes it sort..., Lhydia, 14-Jul-16 09:18 PM, #65
          Reply They were scarce before and experimenting with uknown e..., KaguMaru, 16-Jul-16 05:02 AM, #67
     Reply Two ideas., Shapa, 14-Jul-16 01:44 AM, #58
          Reply RE: Two ideas., Umiron, 14-Jul-16 06:35 AM, #59
          Reply I have a counter suggestion, Kstatida, 14-Jul-16 07:54 AM, #60
               Reply RE: I have a counter suggestion, Shapa, 14-Jul-16 09:36 PM, #66
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #64041 Previous topic | Next topic