Wherein I try to extract cogent arguments from Dirt's posts and brand them as my own in the hopes they might be discussed in a dispassionate manner:

1. Should there be a hard cap on thief points regardless of the source? Possibly 120? Because currently 2x Devious + Reward (i.e. 130) is fairly doable. At level 42 no less.

2. Does giving imm xp (i.e. currency for edges, which confer non-trivial game-play advantages) for role entries distort the way the role command is used and, in fact, not result in better role-play?

3. Does tying edge points to observation/exploration xp just motivate people to "game the system" (by re-observing/exploring areas they've already visited multiple times) and not actually enhance anyone's fun? Instead of the intended effect of rewarding players who do more than just hang around Galadon and Eastern Road, it seems to have rewarded whomever is willing to undertake the monotonous task of exploring/observing the same areas with each successive character.