Isildur | Tue 13-Feb-07 11:14 AM |
Member since 04th Mar 2003
5969 posts
| |
|
#16487, "RE: Good Killing Neutral"
|
>1. It's been historical thing and accepted for a long time >2. Playability (Tarus bracers)
Playability is a non-issue, as is historical precedent. This isn't a court room. If it's bad role-play then it shouldn't matter that such bad role-play was deemed acceptable at various times in the past.
>3. Visiting chessmasters and elsewhere (if any)
This is a perfect example of why "goods killing neutrals" should be taken on a case-by-case basis. Look at the butler. He's a golem. Golems are magical constructs that aren't sentient.
>4. Unfair advantage (If Good can't kill neutral for eq, then >all things considered, Evil has more access to more equipment.
This is just a more specific phrasing of #2 above (playability). As such it's a non-issue. Goods have request, as well as arguably more badass good-specific gear. Amathylar, Defiance, Bal'talon, prayer beads, helm of brilliance...
>I disagree with Phaelim's point "If you want that piece of eq >on the neutral mob, get i off an evil's corpse". That's very >good in theory, but not entirely practical. Firstly, equipment >is important to remain competitive.
What gear do you need in order to be competitive that absolutely requires you to kill a sentient neutral mob who isn't involved in some evil activity? I can't think of any.
|
|
|
Good Killing Neutral
[View all] , Thelleneor, Fri 09-Apr-04 11:49 AM
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Isildur,
13-Feb-07 11:14 AM #50
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Isildur,
13-Feb-07 11:14 AM, #51
you crack me up,
laxman,
13-Feb-07 02:58 PM, #52
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
ellen,
13-Feb-07 10:33 AM, #49
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Boldereth,
12-Apr-04 09:42 AM, #47
The way I handle it...,
Vladamir,
27-Mar-04 07:22 PM, #28
I hope they change it so they just decline. nt,
Cerunnir,
27-Mar-04 07:44 PM, #29
Yeah because actually roleplaying it out is bad for the...,
Vladamir,
27-Mar-04 08:09 PM, #30
It isnt roleplay wise good that Ludan attack you outrig...,
Cerunnir,
27-Mar-04 07:53 PM, #31
Why not?,
Vladamir,
27-Mar-04 08:08 PM, #32
What about. Dispose of his fool, elite dwarven guards. ...,
Cerunnir,
27-Mar-04 08:12 PM, #33
on the other hand,
incognito,
27-Mar-04 10:21 PM, #34
Yes but as a paladin I felt obligated not to stereotype...,
Vladamir,
28-Mar-04 04:23 PM, #35
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Sevarecan,
26-Mar-04 09:48 PM, #19
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Isildur,
26-Mar-04 07:43 PM, #17
Agreed (n/t),
Valguarnera,
26-Mar-04 11:06 PM, #20
Good to have you back, Isildur. (n/t),
Little Timmy (Anonymous),
27-Mar-04 03:46 PM, #27
In CF, the precedent means nothing...so stop using it a...,
Wilhath,
26-Mar-04 03:20 PM, #6
Seeking clarity.,
General_Malaise,
26-Mar-04 03:31 PM, #7
RE: In CF, the precedent means nothing...so stop using ...,
Thelleneor,
26-Mar-04 05:43 PM, #9
I don't think playability is an issue.,
Wilhath,
26-Mar-04 06:22 PM, #10
RE: I don't think playability is an issue.,
Thelleneor,
26-Mar-04 06:56 PM, #14
Generally, yes.,
Wilhath,
27-Mar-04 11:41 AM, #24
RE: Covering wear slots:,
Valguarnera,
27-Mar-04 03:16 PM, #26
Beat me to it, here's what was gonna be my post. :P,
General_Malaise,
26-Mar-04 02:56 PM, #5
For what it's worth...,
nepenthe,
06-Apr-04 09:20 PM, #38
Out of interest, how did your paladin come to wield,
Evil Genius (Anonymous),
07-Apr-04 03:52 AM, #39
RE: Out of interest, how did your paladin come to wield,
nepenthe,
07-Apr-04 05:16 PM, #41
Who cares?,
Moridin,
07-Apr-04 07:36 AM, #43
Why was my answer deleted but his false accusation left...,
Evil Genius (Anonymous),
08-Apr-04 03:25 AM, #44
Text enclosed.,
Valguarnera,
08-Apr-04 03:52 AM, #46
RE: Text enclosed.,
Moridin,
14-Apr-04 03:52 PM, #48
How about requesting from neutrals?,
General_Malaise,
07-Apr-04 09:15 AM, #40
RE: How about requesting from neutrals?,
nepenthe,
07-Apr-04 05:33 PM, #42
That's all...,
General_Malaise,
08-Apr-04 02:08 PM, #45
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Valguarnera,
26-Mar-04 12:56 PM, #3
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Beer,
26-Mar-04 02:47 PM, #4
Quick question,
General_Malaise,
26-Mar-04 03:36 PM, #8
RE: Quick question,
Thelleneor,
26-Mar-04 06:29 PM, #12
RE: Elite dwarven guards.,
Valguarnera,
26-Mar-04 11:10 PM, #21
How about requesting from neutrals?,
General_Malaise,
29-Mar-04 10:24 AM, #36
Why not have neutrals not attack, just evils?,
Cassman,
29-Mar-04 04:48 PM, #37
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Thelleneor,
26-Mar-04 06:27 PM, #11
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Isildur,
27-Mar-04 12:27 AM, #22
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
incognito,
26-Mar-04 12:32 PM, #2
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
shokai,
26-Mar-04 12:30 PM, #1
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Thelleneor,
26-Mar-04 06:42 PM, #13
Play and evil character. Then come back to us.,
Cerunnir,
26-Mar-04 07:23 PM, #15
Playing Evil,
Thelleneor,
26-Mar-04 07:40 PM, #16
Ok, paladins cant kill neutrals.,
Cerunnir,
26-Mar-04 09:08 PM, #18
balance and game mechanics are linked,
incognito,
27-Mar-04 02:23 PM, #25
RE: Good Killing Neutral,
Isildur,
27-Mar-04 12:38 AM, #23
| |
|