Thanks for the feedback.

Given I'm not much into talking about active chars, I'll at least tell you my general view.

As in most cabals, if someone makes a mistake, a one-off, or whatever it may be depending on the severity - there is typically some form of internal nudging in the right direction. A Fort guy kills a goodie? He doesn't get immediate induct none, typically gets a talking to or whatever else. A battlerager fights a non-enemy due to some scuffling but doesn't have a history of it? He gets chastised and told to act right. In my entire experience of playing CF, I've rarely ever seen a toss for a first error kinda thing. That's part of what biases how I think about it.

Should it be so that those above given examples get immediate uninducts or something like that? You could argue it, but that's definitely not my view in general, and I'm clearly not partial to it outside of exceptional negative circumstances.

As to Vindicator, keep in mind it's not a leadership position. It doesn't have leader con or anything like that. It doesn't even have decision-making authority outside of very specific circumstances and situations. So in this situation, nobody had a leader position to lose. Vindicator/Justiciar are closer to third-branch / alternate paths somewhat separate from Magistrate to Provincial to Provost.

Anyway, I hope that gives you some context generally about how I view things, and why I would handle things the way I do. All the same I appreciate the feedback, and I promise that no situation like that is a simple glance and just whimsically tossed internal punishment. It normally results in a hefty look, discussion, and so on.

Sorry I “wasted my time” by responding to you (I don’t get why you said that), and I hope this doesn’t turn you off more, but instead that it gives you some extra context for how things might be decided.

Good job with Ihjezhed, I generally liked what I saw from him. If you felt a bit bored due to lack of enemies, like someone else said… Roll up a mage. Heck, do an evil mage, then just hang around Battle and Fort and you should barely have room to breathe. Sometimes general shifts in cabals, etc. result in a surplus/lack of enemies. So just switch to the underdog!

-Ish