While this sounds good in theory, my major concerns would be accusations of favoritism and judgment. We are hardly infallible, and both past history of Immortal objectivity and thoughts of how even I might feel as a player on the bandwagon side if I were to die because of someone actively receiving Immortal help.

That said, I certainly agree with the root idea and some benefit of a form of automation is the removal of possible accusations of unfair bias.

Also, the underdog that does put up the good fight HAS traditionally been the sort to be rewarded, haven't they?