I don't know that I can say it seems like the same player every time, or that it's happened to me as often -- but on three occasions it has gone down exactly like this. I'm about to raid and retrieve when, boom, I'm warranted for aiding criminals or burning cities (amusingly, once on a Harbinger). So while I don't share the other player's present vehemence, I can attest to there being an issue with this. And, I humbly and respectfully disagree with you, Ish - it's not good Outlander RP to make any kind of effort (even one veiled as braggadocio) to remove a bad flag.

I think what is more bothersome to me is the Provost raiding Outlander with an Orc over and over again. It does seem like maybe, possibly, could-be-that-maybe a little more enforcement of RP is needed for Tribunal. Maybe? Possibly?