Which statement is more logical.

(The argument you just used, which has nothing to do with my argument)
Out of all of the people that you know or have contact with, there are two or three liars, thus you are a liar.

(The argument I used, which has nothing to do with your argument that you used to discredit my argument)
Out of all of the people in your city, all of the friends that you have chosen are members of the KKK, thus there is a high probability that you have some sort of race-issues.


Which of those two statements sounds logical?

Do they use the same logic? If one of them is illogical, does that mean the other is illogical, as your post seemed to imply?




"Death awaits ya all, wit nasteh big pointeh teeth!"