>So, Tribunal is not inherently evil. The only thing you are
>joining yourself with, or allying yourself with when you join
>Tribunal, is the Spire/Law. This isn't Empire. You don't
>"serve" the Trib imm or the Provost. You serve the cities
>that are protected.


That's the view I took as a mortal, but both of your views would work for a character for both of your reasons.

IC, this is the biggest "schism" within the paladin guild, I think. It also can lead to some conflict, cool RP, and difficult choices to make, all of which make the game more fun.

It would be more boaring if one way was set in stone and I'll leave it at that.