I certainly, a hundred percent, totally disagree with you.
The idea is, if you were an evil-aligned race, like a
drow, fire giant, or duergar, then you do have a penchant
to do evil things, you just do, unless you are a freak of
the race and are seeking redemption.

Drow Invoker Master: Don't know any of the top of my head,
but I'm sure as a PC Valguarnera was too busy dealing with
Sylvans and Battle, and was a "studying magic and barely
care for anything else" looking guy, but from an RP-history
standpoint, his actions and an Imperial Arcanus' created
the Scion cabal.

Duergar Tribunal: Never met a truly evil duergar tribunal,
but what about a evil human healer tribunal like Onirakoth.
An evil in power in Tribunal can do all sorts of bad crap,
Onirakoth was known for causing a ruckus with the Fortress.
But, like in my original post, a duergar in tribunal could
be a "Predisposed Evil" however, and -perhaps- shouldn't be
hunted.

Drow Troupe: Same thing, but if he involves himself in
assisting other evils, or directly or indirectly harming
Forties/Goods, or furthering CF RP plotlines in an evil
manner, then he could be a problem!

Yeah, I agree Maran should take these things into
consideration and not just ruthlessly gang everything that
has (Red Aura) around it, some Maran lose a little style
points for not trying a little redemption talk first, but
for the most part, it's not too bad.

I think what you really want is to see goodies being more
diplomatic and discerning about their targets, which is not
a Shokai-esque "Kill all with Red Aura" religion-friendly
point of view, and although the Maran religion is different
from Maran cabal, they still bare a big ole resemblence.

Anyways, that's that, I need sleep.

- Runaktla

PS: Good job as Emperor