Sure, it was 4 years or so since my last character, so I'm ok with the punishment, but me killing poacher is a noob mistake. Me killing Arkham guard in one round, when he attacks a raiding party of marans with 2 items of power on them, when I am not leading, and theres actually nothing I could do to stop it (mechaniclly) (Oh other than lose my warrant which lets face it, its not like I didnt fight tribunals?). Afk killing a cityguard that tracks me from Galadon into the fortress, nothing I can do here other than logging out. Its game though you know, and even I need to have a drink of tea or take a whizz.

I dunno man if you kill something in self defence, you should feel bad, but I dont think you should be punished for it. You have other ideas and thats fine.